5 Places To Stay On Anna Maria Island > Penny-Pincher’s Paradise

Being among Florida’s pricier vacation spots, many vacationers seek cheap places to stay on Anna Maria Island. Despite the challenge, several budget-friendly options offer quality stays without draining your wallet.

Once a local hidden gem in Florida, Anna Maria, a seven-mile barrier island is now a highly sought-after vacation spot. Renowned for its pristine beaches, vibrant Gulf waters, and charming districts, it appeals to a wide array of travelers, from honeymooners to Hollywood crews to everyday Americans. In brief, the once-hidden gem is now widely known and popular, attracting vacation seekers from all corners.

Anna Maria Island: Authentic, genuine, and charming, it captivates with pristine beaches, local charm, and a laid-back atmosphere.

Vintage Simplicity

Nestled at the confluence of Tampa Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, Anna Maria Island boasts “Old Florida” charm like no other. With no towering highrise structures, the island invites exploration by bike, on foot, or aboard a free trolley, revealing cozy homes near the water’s edge.

With sugar-white sands and emerald-blue waters, these serene beaches on Anna Maria Island offer a timeless and tranquil coastal escape.

Vacationers enjoy navigating the picturesque inlets and canals by kayak or chartering a fishing boat, immersing in an untouched coastal landscape. With an average temperature of 75º F, this year-round retreat beckons with fantastic restaurants and pristine Gulf Coast beaches, where soft sands meet the turquoise embrace of the sea, culminating in breathtaking sunsets—of course, none of this charm and wow factor comes cheaply.

Affordable Places To Stay On Anna Maria Island

Although there are bargains on the island, a vacation to Anna Maria is not synonymous with affordability. In reality, it is a relatively expensive destination, particularly for those unaccustomed to Florida’s high cost of living.

We’d like to manage expectations upfront—finding accommodations at $100 per night on the island is unlikely. Realistically, even the most economical options on Anna Maria Island fall within the $250 to $300 per night range.

The Legacy Hotel at IMG is only about a 10-minute drive from Bradenton Beach. We’re seeing rates here for as low as $233 per night!

If this exceeds your budget, consider exploring Bradenton, where both Hampton Inn & Suites Bradenton and Legacy Hotel at IMG Academy, just a short drive from Anna Maria Island, offer rates closer to $200 per night. Both offer fantastic amenities, providing great value.

🏨 Hampton Inn & Suites Bradenton > Check Availability

However, if your heart is set on an Anna Maria Island retreat, explore the finest budget-savvy options below.

5 Affordable Places To Stay On Anna Maria Island

Based on our experience, the budget-friendly beach accommodations below provide a nice balance of location, cleanliness, and amenities. Furthermore, these places offer excellent proximity to the beach, comfort, cleanliness, and essential amenities and facilities. Finally, they’re all centrally located between Holmes and Bradenton beaches.

1. Bridgewalk, a Landmark Resort

Bridgewalk on Anna Maria Island: A landmark resort blending historic charm and modern comfort, offering a genuine island experience.

Ideally situated on historic Bridge Street in Bradenton Beach, BridgeWalk Resort puts you in the heart of Anna Maria Island’s vibrant scene. Walk to top restaurants and shops, explore with the trolley, and enjoy complimentary beach amenities. Unwind in spacious rooms, lounge by the pool, and embrace a captivating family vacation—this is the best bang for the buck on the island!

🏨 Bridgewalk Resort > Check Availability

Top-5 Tours on Anna Maria Island

💡 After you’ve hit up the beach and taken a historic stroll down Pine Avenue, add one of these thrilling tours to your itinerary!

2. Queens Gate Resort

Experience the charm of Queens Gate Resort—an inviting, tranquil haven reminiscent of days past. Enjoy their private beach, heated pool, and serene tropical setting for unforgettable vacation memories.

Emanating old-world charm, Queen’s Gate Resort delivers an authentic island experience!

At Queens Gate, the celebration of witnessing breathtaking, beautiful sunsets awaits you on our private beach directly across the street. Moreover, their swaying palm trees and tropical gardens can be an irresistibly refreshing oasis.

🏨 Queens Gate Resort > Check Availability

3. Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages

As a tranquil retreat, Cedar Cove offers serene accommodations with a touch of luxury, just steps from Bradenton Beach.

Located on Holmes Beach, Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages offers 4-star accommodations with free bikes, parking, and captivating views. Enjoy elegant luxury suites and Key West-style cottages, each equipped with modern amenities. Experience a perfect vacation with beachside cabanas, sun decks, and tiki huts!

🏨 Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages > Check Availability

4. Tortuga Inn Beach Resort

The seaside sanctuary of Tortuga Inn & Resort marries comfort with coastal elegance, offering a serene retreat near pristine Gulf waters.

As a family-friendly retreat, Tortuga Inn Beach Resort features spacious studios and apartments, adorned with beach-inspired decor, and boasts fully equipped kitchens and patios. Furthermore, the property features three pools, including an exclusive Bayfront unit overlook, a water sports dock, and a cozy cafe offering coffee and breakfast treats. Complimentary Wi-Fi and beach accessories enhance the overall value.

🏨 Tortuga Inn Beach Resort > Check Availability

5. Tradewinds Beach Resort

A cozy coastal escape, Tradewinds Beach Resort seamlessly blends homely beach-themed charm with proximity to a stunning white sand beach.

Nestled between a secluded beach and a prime fishing bay, TradeWinds Beach Resort is a cozy beach-themed haven. Moreover, its 33 vintage-style apartment rooms, while dated, offer spacious retreats with full kitchens and living areas. Finally, the resort features an outdoor heated pool, complimentary beach accessories, and guest laundry facilities.

🏨 Tradewinds Beach Resort > Check Availability

Consider These Prime Budget-Savvy Vacation Rentals

Vacation rentals provide privacy, space, and a homely atmosphere, enhancing the beach vacation experience with comfort and flexibility. Three of the best budget-savvy vacation rentals on Anna Maria Island are listed below:

1. Large Beach House – Sleeps 10
This large vacation rental sleeps up to 10!

Secluded 4-bedroom beach house in historic Longboat Village, a short walk to the beach and top restaurants. Fully remodeled with amenities. Enjoy outdoor dining and a fire pit evening.

🏡 Large Beach House > Check Availability

2. Cozy Couple Retreat – Sleeps 2
Couples will find this pink palace ultra-romantic!

In the heart of Bradenton Beach, the Pink House Cozy Couple Retreat is a charming studio with a private kitchen and balcony, steps from the ocean. Convenient trolley and Monkey Bus access.

🏡 Cozy Couple Retreat > Check Availability

3. Dog-Friendly Duplex – Sleeps 6
Families with a dog will find this condo very comfortable.

Find serenity in Bradenton Beach, two blocks from the beach and under a mile from the city center. This dog-friendly ground-floor duplex offers a shared heated pool, patio, outdoor dining, and grill. Inside, a sunny living area with a smart TV, a fully-equipped kitchen, and bedrooms with smart TVs await.

🏡 Dog-Friendly Duplex > Check Availability

Generations have embraced Anna Maria Island for its timeless allure—white sands, nature, and an old Florida charm. While no longer a hidden gem, this quaint barrier island south of Tampa Bay maintains an authentic atmosphere. Recent transformations, particularly along Pine Avenue, have breathed new life into hotels, residences, and businesses, adopting vibrant beach-style architecture. The result is an idyllic retreat, offering respite from the daily hustle and bustle of modern life.

We Need Your Help

Did you find this article helpful? If so, bookmark it and when you’re planning your next vacation click on any of the links below before finalizing reservations. You’ll get the best price, we’ll earn a small commission, and you’ll help support future articles.

Thank you!


🏘️ Book Your Accommodation

We use Tripadvisor and Priceline’s Express Deals to compare prices and reviews in advance and check availability

✈️ Book Your Flight in Advance

To find the cheapest flight options, you can use CheapOAir and Skyscanner to find the most suitable choice for you

🚗 Reserve Your Rental Car

Use DiscoverCars and Skyscanner to compare prices and view the largest selection of vehicles

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply